Libavogadro and Eigen

Dear All:
First of all, happy new year
I have been quite inactive lately due to familiar problems, I am happy to see
that a lot of new things have been already done.
Respect to the use of Eigen for libavogadro, Kalzium and likely Kryomol…
These templates are designed for row major C-matrices, however if would be
great if storage could be also done as column major since most linear algebra
libraries are fortran based (LAPACK).
I will start the porting of Kryomol to KDE4 next month and I will use now
libavogadro for the rendering engine, I will report all the problems I face.

Only one thing, I think that methods such as getMolecule should be also
duplicatead as const Molecule* getMolecule() const for const correctness.

And finally one problem I have been struggling with Kryomol, the propietary
ATI drivers are linked against libstdc++.so.5, however most systems
implemente now libstdc++.so.6, I dont know why ( should not be versioned the
libraries ? ), KryoMol is calling std library from both versions and nasty
memory errors take place. Anyone of you have any idea how to tackle the
problem?

My best wishes

–
Dr. Armando Navarro-Vázquez
Departamento de quimica organica
Universidade de Santiago de Compostela
http://desoft03.usc.es/armando/index.html

Hi Armando

On Mon, 8 Jan 2007, Armando Navarro Vázquez wrote:

Respect to the use of Eigen for libavogadro, Kalzium and likely Kryomol…
These templates are designed for row major C-matrices,

No, Eigen uses colum-major storage, like OpenGL :slight_smile: don’t know where you
got the impression that it used row-major storage from :slight_smile:

And thanks for your interest in Eigen, you’re making the right choice :slight_smile:

however if would be
great if storage could be also done as column major since most linear algebra
libraries are fortran based (LAPACK).

Well, if they use column-major storage, then all is fine since that’s what
Eigen uses; however I seem to remember that some of the “big libraries”
propose the two possibilities, column-major or row-major.

If you ever had a need for that, one could consider also providing the two
possibilities in Eigen. Eigen is extensible in that respect.
However I won’t do it unless there’s a real need for it.

I will start the porting of Kryomol to KDE4 next month and I will use now
libavogadro for the rendering engine, I will report all the problems I face.

Cool news, I’m of course also considering porting Kalzium 3d to
libavogadro, however that’ll have to wait until I have some time :slight_smile:

And finally one problem I have been struggling with Kryomol, the propietary
ATI drivers are linked against libstdc++.so.5, however most systems
implemente now libstdc++.so.6, I dont know why ( should not be versioned the
libraries ? ), KryoMol is calling std library from both versions and nasty
memory errors take place. Anyone of you have any idea how to tackle the
problem?

I don’t know a solution, sorry. I can only suggest that you don’t spend
time on this problem: it’s a problem in ATI’s drivers, not in your own
software. Just refuse to do more work just because ATI didn’t do its own
work properly. The best you can do is e-mail ATI about that, and in
KryoMol use the GL_RENDERER or GL_VENDOR string to detect when the ATI
proprietary driver is used, and in that case let the user know that
because of a bug in the ATI driver, the app might crash. Just so the user
doesn’t believe it’s KryoMol’s fault.

Benoit

Only one thing, I think that methods such as getMolecule should be also
duplicatead as const Molecule* getMolecule() const for const correctness.

Yeah no problem. One area i’m REALLY bad at is doing const’s. I never
figure where it’s really important to do so and so i normally just hope
everything plays nice. I in no way think it’s a good thing. I’ll do
what i can and any place you feel there should be a const let me know.

Just a word of warning. While libavogadro is pretty stable it’s still
very new. The engines haven’t all been converted to the new plugin
style (right now only ball and stick) and i haven’t finallized all the
function calls. However all interface to and from the GLWidget is
pretty much set which is really all you guys need. So it should be very
close. I don’t want to discourage you though because having two major
projects use it will definatly help it’s development. Thanks for the
interest.

-Donald