I’ll reply to Henry’s message sometime this morning.
-Geoff
Begin forwarded message:
From: “Rzepa, Henry” h.rzepa@imperial.ac.uk
Date: July 2, 2008 4:33:03 AM EDT
To: Geoffrey Hutchison geoff.hutchison@gmail.com
Subject: General comments on the UI in AvogadroGeoff,
I have decided that we can "go’ with Avogadro for the start of our
teaching term (October), and have started some preliminary
documentation.This has given me a few ideas suggestions/queries.
- There are essentially three areas students need to be familiar
with.
(a) the little strip of 9 tools icons on the left, probably the
MOST useful (which, once floated and then closed cannot be re-
instated?)
(b) several of the application menu items, ie build/add remove Hs,
or Extensions/mechanics/calculate energy
(c) The display types pane on the bottom left (which, once floated
and then closed cannot be re-instated?)There is also a row of icons along the very top (new, open, etc)
which appear to be duplicates of the application file menu, and do
not really seem to serve a purpose? They can be hidden, but I do
not think they should appear by default? Is it possible to reset
the prefs to default? Once a pane is minimised, or closed, it can be
a trial to make it appear again.I am wondering how much to explain, and it seemed that the two items
in (b) could be moved to the tools strip?, and that perhaps the
Display types, which occupies a lot of space, could also somehow be
made into a tool?A display bug (0.8.1) overlays the caption ---- Debug information
---- directly over the instantaneous energy being reported in the
autoOptimisation modefinally, some selections clearly fight eachother. Thus trying to
invoke the measure tool whilst auto-optimization is on produces a
rapidly and unreadable display of instantaneous measurements. Could
eg invoking this tool be made to automatically switch OFF the auto-
optimisation?Overall, I feel Avogadro is rapidly becoming student usable, but the
menus are at the moment providing too much information for such
users, and a minimalist approach might be useful?Warmest wishes,
Henry Rzepa.
+44 (020) 7594 5774 (Voice); http://www.ch.ic.ac.uk/rzepa/rzepa.xrdf
(FOAF)
Henry S. Rzepa Dept. Chemistry, Imperial College
London, SW7 2AZ, UK.(Voracious anti-spam filter in operation for received email.
If expected reply not received, please phone/fax).